I'm still having the same issue and it's really bugging me. Had to swap out router hardware so I figured I'd start fresh. Brand new install of PFsense 2.4.4p2. No packages, VPN, multi-wan, or anything else set up yet.
Setup:
I have Comcast business internet with 5 static IPs. All WAN info is entered correctly. Usable IP range is XX.XX.XXX.201 through XX.XX.XXX.205, Gateway is XX.XX.XXX.206. Static IP in the WAN interface is XX.XX.XXX.201/29. LAN network is simply 192.168.2.0/24, DHCP on. That's it. Nothing else. Very simple and standard so far.
What's Working:
I have a Plex server with a local IP of 192.168.2.222. I made a virtual IP using IP Alias for my second usable static IP of XX.XX.XXX.202. Made a NAT rule with .202 as the destination and pointing to my Plex server's local IP at 192.168.2.222 (with the appropriate ports forwarded of...