I am at my wits end and have reached the stage, where I've been looking at the problem for so long now that it's like proof reading your own work, aka can't see anything wrong.
I have searched for solutions for nearly a week now, and please trust me this is what I currently have set up, but have tried countless variations also.
I feel it's a firewall/NAT issue but again can't seem to isolate where.
I have a fresh install of pfSense 2.5 with acme and haproxy-devel installed.
I have updated the pfSense webgui to port 8443.
I have two rules in WAN:
ProtocolSourcePortDestinationPort Gateway Queue Schedule Description Actions
IPv4 TCP * *This Firewall 80 (HTTP) *none
IPv4 TCP * *This Firewall 443 (HTTPS)*none
Lets-encrypt is all set up with a wildcard cert.
I have no Port forward, 1:1 rules No NAT outbound Mappings with Mode set to Automatic.
...